Analysis on status quo of outcomes and measurement instruments of randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia

CAO Wen-cong; QIU Xing-ying; LIU Bing-qing; LI Geng; WEN Ze-huai

doi:10.13703/j.0255-2930.20220217-k0007

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Analysis on status quo of outcomes and measurement instruments of randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia

Literature Research | 更新时间：2024-06-03

- Analysis on status quo of outcomes and measurement instruments of randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia
- Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion Vol. 43, Issue 9, Pages: 1086-1093(2023)
- 作者机构：
  
  1.广州中医药大学第二临床医学院，广东广州 510405
  2.广东省中医院临床研究方法学重点研究室，广州 510120
  3.广东省中医院省部共建中医湿证国家重点实验室，广州 510120
  4.广州中医药大学DME中心，广东广州 510405
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：10.13703/j.0255-2930.20220217-k0007
  CLC： R 245
- Received：17 February 2022，
  
  Online First：14 August 2023，
  
  Published：12 September 2023
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
曹文聪,邱幸莹,刘冰清等.针刺治疗卒中后吞咽困难随机对照试验结局及其测量工具现状分析[J].中国针灸,2023,43(09):1086-1093.

CAO Wen-cong,QIU Xing-ying,LIU Bing-qing,et al.Analysis on status quo of outcomes and measurement instruments of randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia[J].Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion,2023,43(09):1086-1093.
曹文聪,邱幸莹,刘冰清等.针刺治疗卒中后吞咽困难随机对照试验结局及其测量工具现状分析[J].中国针灸,2023,43(09):1086-1093. DOI： 10.13703/j.0255-2930.20220217-k0007.

CAO Wen-cong,QIU Xing-ying,LIU Bing-qing,et al.Analysis on status quo of outcomes and measurement instruments of randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia[J].Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion,2023,43(09):1086-1093. DOI： 10.13703/j.0255-2930.20220217-k0007.

摘要

目的

分析针刺治疗卒中后吞咽困难随机对照试验（RCT）结局及其测量工具的报告情况，为其临床试验设计及构建核心结局指标集提供依据。

方法

检索中国期刊全文数据库（CNKI）、中国生物医学文献服务系统（SinoMed）、万方学术期刊全文数据库（Wanfang）、PubMed、EMbase、Web of Science及ClinicalTrials.gov、中国临床试验注册中心（ChiCTR）针刺治疗卒中后吞咽困难的RCT，检索日期为2012年1月1日至2021年10月30日，通过文献筛选和资料提取汇总结局指标及其测量工具并进行整理和分析。

结果

共纳入172项研究（165项RCT，7项在研试验注册方案）。涉及91个结局指标，可按照功能属性分为临床表现、理化检查、生活质量、中医症状/证候、远期预后、安全性评价及经济学评估7类指标域。结局指标的选用存在测量工具种类多、差异大、评价时点不统一及报告不分主次等问题。

结论

针刺治疗卒中后吞咽困难RCT结局及其测量工具现状不利于各个试验结果的汇总和比较。建议构建该类临床研究的核心结局指标集，以提高其临床试验设计的规范性和研究质量。

Abstract

Objective

To analyze the report status of outcomes and measurement instruments of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia

so as to provide a basis for designing clinical trials and developing the core outcome set in acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia.

Methods

RCTs of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia were searched in databases i.e. CNKI

SinoMed

Wanfang

PubMed

EMbase

Web of Science and clinical trial registries i.e. ClinicalTrials.gov and Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (ChiCTR)

from January 1st

2012 to October 30th

2021. By literature screening and data extraction

outcomes and measurement instruments were summarized and analyzed.

Results

A total of 172 trials (including 165 RCTs and 7 ongoing trials registrations) were included

involving 91 outcomes. The outcomes could be classified into 7 domains according to functional attributes

namely clinical manifestation

physical and chemical examination

quality of life

TCM symptoms/syndromes

long-term prognosis

safety assessment and economic evaluation. It was found that there were various measurements instruments with large differences

inconsistent measurement time point and without discriminatively reporting primary or secondary outcomes.

Conclusion

The status quo of outcomes and measurement instruments of RCTs of acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia is not conducive to the summary and comparison of each trial's results. Thus

it is suggested to develop a core outcome set for acupuncture for post-stroke dysphagia to improve the normative and research quality of their clinical trial design.

关键词

Keywords

references

Fernandes HM , Gregson B , Siddique S , et al . Surgery in intracerebral hemorrhage. The uncertainty continues [J ] . Stroke , 2000 , 31 ( 10 ): 2511 - 2516 .

Hackett ML , Duncan JR , Anderson CS , et al . Health-related quality of life among long-term survivors of stroke: results from the Auckland Stroke Study, 1991-1992 [J ] . Stroke , 2000 , 31 ( 2 ): 440 - 447 .

杨慧婷 , 蒋金兰 , 金林珍 , 等 . 针灸治疗中风恢复期临床预测模型的建立和分析 [J ] . 中国针灸 , 2021 , 41 ( 8 ): 855 - 860 .

Dziewas R , Michou E , Trapl-Grundschober M , et al . European Stroke Organisation and European Society for Swallowing Disorders guideline for the diagnosis and treatment of post-stroke dysphagia [J ] . Eur Stroke J , 2021 , 6 ( 3 ): LXXXIX-CXV.

Martino R , Foley N , Bhogal S , et al . Dysphagia after stroke: incidence, diagnosis, and pulmonary complications [J ] . Stroke , 2005 , 36 ( 12 ): 2756 - 2763 .

Bath PM , Lee HS , Everton LF . Swallowing therapy for dysphagia in acute and subacute stroke [J ] . Cochrane Database Syst Rev , 2018 , 10 ( 10 ): CD000323 .

Attrill S , White S , Murray J , et al . Impact of oropharyngeal dysphagia on healthcare cost and length of stay in hospital: a systematic review [J ] . BMC Health Serv Res , 2018 , 18 ( 1 ): 594 .

González-Fernández M , Ottenstein L , Atanelov L , et al . Dysphagia after stroke: an overview [J ] . Curr Phys Med Rehabil Rep , 2013 , 1 ( 3 ): 187 - 196 .

Terré R . Oropharyngeal dysphagia in stroke: diagnostic and therapeutic aspects [J ] . Rev Neurol , 2020 , 70 ( 12 ): 444 - 452 .

Zhong LD , Wang J , Li F , et al . The effectiveness of acupuncture for dysphagia after stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J ] . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med , 2021 , 2021 : 8837625 .

Jiang HL , Zhang Q , Zhao Q , et al . Manual acupuncture or combination of rehabilitation therapy to treat poststroke dysphagia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J ] . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med , 2022 , 2022 : 8803507 .

Lu L , Zhang XG , Zhong LL , et al . Acupuncture for neurogenesis in experimental ischemic stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J ] . Sci Rep , 2016 , 6 : 19521 .

Yang JL . Acupuncture treatment for post-stroke insomnia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J ] . Complement Ther Clin Pract , 2021 , 44 : 101396 .

Birch S , Robinson N . Acupuncture as a post-stroke treatment option: a narrative review of clinical guideline recommendations [J ] . Phytomedicine , 2022 , 104 : 154297 .

王惟一 . 新刊补注铜人腧穴针灸图经校注 [M ] . 朱现民校注 . 郑州 : 河南科学技术出版社 , 2015 .

Sang BM , Deng SZ , Zhai JB , et al . Does acupuncture therapy improve language function of patients with aphasia following ischemic stroke? A systematic review and meta-analysis [J ] . NeuroRehabilitation , 2022 , 51 ( 2 ): 231 - 245 .

Uchida S , Hotta H . Acupuncture affects regional blood flow in various organs [J ] . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med , 2008 , 5 ( 2 ): 145 - 151 .

邢冬梅 , 张俊华 , 张伯礼 . 中医临床研究核心结局指标集形成路径 [J ] . 中华中医药杂志 , 2014 , 29 ( 5 ): 1352 - 1355 .

于长禾 , 孙亚男 , 何丽云 , 等 . 建立中医药临床研究核心结局指标集 [J ] . 中华中医药杂志 , 2016 , 31 ( 7 ): 2526 - 2529 .

万颖 , 刘长信 , 周彦吉 , 等 . 从中医药核心结局指标集研究反观干预措施在核心结局指标集的地位 [J ] . 中华中医药杂志 , 2021 , 36 ( 4 ): 2276 - 2281 .

Williamson PR , Altman DG , Bagley H , et al . The COMET handbook: version 1.0 [J ] . Trials , 2017 , 18 ( suppl 3 ): 280 .

生晓迪 , 陈超 , 张婷 , 等 . 中医药治疗风湿性心脏病随机对照试验评价指标的现状分析 [J ] . 中国中药杂志 , 2022 , 47 ( 1 ): 244 - 252 .

Tugwell P , Knottnerus JA . Whither core outcome sets? [J ] . J Clin Epidemiol , 2014 , 67 ( 7 ): 731 - 733 .

彭斌 , 刘鸣 , 崔丽英 . 与时俱进的新指南: 《中国急性缺血性脑卒中诊治指南2018》解读 [J ] . 中华神经科杂志 , 2018 , 51 ( 9 ): 657 - 659 .

王丽平 , 解越 . 针灸治疗卒中后吞咽困难的系统评价 [J ] . 中国针灸 , 2006 , 26 ( 2 ): 141 - 146 .

张明妍 , 张俊华 , 张伯礼 , 等 . 中医药临床试验核心指标集研制技术规范 [J ] . 中华中医药杂志 , 2021 , 36 ( 2 ): 924 - 928 .

王彦华 , 周红霞 , 杨国防 , 等 . 项针为主治疗脑卒中后吞咽困难30例 [J ] . 中医研究 , 2017 , 30 ( 6 ): 68 - 70 .

罗艳丽 . 体针联合腹针治疗脑卒中后吞咽困难随机平行对照研究 [J ] . 实用中医内科杂志 , 2016 , 30 ( 4 ): 101 - 103 .

张惠利 , 朱立春 , 卜秀焕 , 等 . 中风后吞咽困难评价量表的研究进展 [J ] . 中西医结合心脑血管病杂志 , 2014 , 12 ( 11 ): 1390 - 1391 .

张婧 , 王拥军 , 崔韬 . 脑卒中后吞咽困难9个评价量表的信度及效度研究 [J ] . 中国临床康复 , 2004 , 8 ( 7 ): 1201 - 1203 .

武文娟 , 毕霞 , 宋磊 , 等 . 洼田饮水试验在急性脑卒中后吞咽障碍患者中的应用价值 [J ] . 上海交通大学学报(医学版) , 2016 , 36 ( 7 ): 1049 - 1053 .

伍少玲 , 马超 , 黄粉燕 , 等 . 标准吞咽功能评定量表的临床应用研究 [J ] . 中华物理医学与康复杂志 , 2008 , 30 ( 6 ): 396 - 399 .

马月利 , 张黎明 , 祝勤雅 , 等 . 标准吞咽功能评定量表应用于高龄患者吞咽功能评估的信效度研究 [J ] . 护理学报 , 2012 , 19 ( 5 ): 65 - 67 .

谭嘉升 , 丘卫红 , 刘中良 , 等 . 中文版吞咽生命质量量表信度和效度的研究 [J ] . 中华物理医学与康复杂志 , 2016 , 38 ( 9 ): 669 - 673 .

Kraus EM , Rommel N , Stoll LH , et al . Validation and psychometric properties of the German version of the SWAL-QOL [J ] . Dysphagia , 2018 , 33 ( 4 ): 431 - 440 .

McHorney CA , Bricker DE , Robbins J , et al . The SWAL-QOL outcomes tool for oropharyngeal dysphagia in adults: Ⅱ. Item reduction and preliminary scaling [J ] . Dysphagia , 2000 , 15 ( 3 ): 122 - 133 .

Rivelsrud MC , Kirmess M , Hartelius L . Cultural adaptation and validation of the Norwegian version of the swallowing quality of life questionnaire (SWAL-QOL) [J ] . Health Qual Life Outcomes , 2019 , 17 ( 1 ): 179 .

Kim SY , Kim TU , Hyun JK , et al . Differences in videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS) findings according to the vascular territory involved in stroke [J ] . Dysphagia , 2014 , 29 ( 4 ): 444 - 449 .

牛丽 , 李彦杰 , 秦合伟 , 等 . 脑卒中后吞咽障碍康复评估和治疗研究进展 [J ] . 中国医药导报 , 2020 , 17 ( 28 ): 48 - 51, 63 .

Li G , Han RX , Cao WC , et al . Outcome reporting variability in trials of Chinese medicine for hyperlipidemia: a systematic review for developing a core outcome set [J ] . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med , 2021 , 2021 : 8822215 .

Moher D , Hopewell S , Schulz KF , et al . CONSORT 2010 explanation and elaboration: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials [J ] . Int J Surg , 2012 , 10 ( 1 ): 28 - 55 .

刘炳林 , 薛斐然 . 临床试验中疗效指标观察与测量相关问题的考虑 [J ] . 中国新药杂志 , 2019 , 28 ( 24 ): 2939 - 2947 .

Vetter TR , Mascha EJ . Defining the primary outcomes and justifying secondary outcomes of a study: usually, the fewer, the better [J ] . Anesth Analg , 2017 , 125 ( 2 ): 678 - 681 .

Andrade C . The primary outcome measure and its importance in clinical trials [J ] . J Clin Psychiatry , 2015 , 76 ( 10 ): e1320 - e1323 .

Altman DG , Schulz KF , Moher D , 等 . 报告随机对照试验的CONSORT声明修订版: 说明与详述(二) [J ] . 中国实用内科杂志 , 2006 , 26 ( 6 ): 470 - 471 .

Altman DG , Schulz KF , Moher D , 等 . 报告随机对照试验的CONSORT声明修订版: 说明与详述(八) [J ] . 中国实用内科杂志 , 2006 , 26 ( 20 ): 1663 - 1664 .

邢冬梅 , 牟玮 , 张俊华 , 等 . 有效性试验核心结局测量指标简介及启迪 [J ] . 中国新药与临床杂志 , 2014 , 33 ( 4 ): 252 - 256 .

Ioannidis JPA , Evans SJW , Gøtzsche PC , et al . Better reporting of harms in randomized trials: an extension of the CONSORT statement [J ] . Ann Intern Med , 2004 , 141 ( 10 ): 781 - 788 .

胡瑞学 , 熊兴江 , 陈仁波 , 等 . 近两年中医药干预原发性高血压病临床试验结局指标的分析 [J ] . 中国中药杂志 , 2021 , 46 ( 6 ): 1547 - 1557 .

温泽淮 . 中医临床疗效评价内容与研究策略的思考 [J ] . 中国中西医结合杂志 , 2011 , 31 ( 4 ): 452 - 454 .

张宇 . 针灸治疗中风后吞咽障碍临床证据评估及卫生经济学评价 [D ] . 广州 : 广州中医药大学 , 2020 .

Views

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

Research status and prospects of electroencephalogram characteristics in acupuncture for cognitive dysfunction

Research progress on the regulatory mechanisms of inflammatory signaling pathways in acupuncture treatment for ischemic stroke

Professor YIN Kejing′s clinical experience in treating Meige′s syndrome with four-penetrating Yangbai (GB14) combined with double-needle connection technique

A decade of breakthroughs in high-quality clinical research on acupuncture: deep transformation and paradigm reconstruction marching towards evidence-based medicine

Application and insights of multimodal imaging in acupuncture treatment for female stress urinary incontinence

Related Author

WANG Xiaome

WU Sixian

YU Hanbo

ZHANG Yid

ZHANG Dingchen

LI Guiping

XIA Wenxin

LI Xiaoxiao

Related Institution

Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, First Teaching Hospital of Tianjin University of TCM

National Clinical Research Center for Chinese Medicine

Graduate School, Tianjin University of TCM

Institute of Neurology, Anhui University of CM

Wannan Medical College

⁰