Re-evaluation of systematic reviews of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy

LU Xiao-fei; TAO Ya-wen; LIU Fan; XU Yu-qin; GONG Ming-qiang; YANG Zhuo-xin

doi:10.13703/j.0255-2930.20221008-0004

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Re-evaluation of systematic reviews of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy

Literature Research | 更新时间：2024-06-03

- Re-evaluation of systematic reviews of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy
- Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion Vol. 43, Issue 10, Pages: 1209-1216(2023)
- 作者机构：
  
  1.广州中医药大学第四临床医学院，广东深圳518000
  2.深圳市中医院针灸科，广东深圳518000
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：10.13703/j.0255-2930.20221008-0004
  CLC： R 246.4
- Received：08 October 2022，
  
  Online First：07 August 2023，
  
  Published：12 October 2023
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
陆晓菲,陶雅文,刘凡等.针灸治疗小儿脑瘫疗效的系统评价再评价[J].中国针灸,2023,43(10):1209-1216.

LU Xiao-fei,TAO Ya-wen,LIU Fan,et al.Re-evaluation of systematic reviews of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy[J].Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion,2023,43(10):1209-1216.
陆晓菲,陶雅文,刘凡等.针灸治疗小儿脑瘫疗效的系统评价再评价[J].中国针灸,2023,43(10):1209-1216. DOI： 10.13703/j.0255-2930.20221008-0004.

LU Xiao-fei,TAO Ya-wen,LIU Fan,et al.Re-evaluation of systematic reviews of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy[J].Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion,2023,43(10):1209-1216. DOI： 10.13703/j.0255-2930.20221008-0004.

摘要

目的

对针灸治疗小儿脑瘫疗效的Meta分析和系统评价进行方法学质量、报告质量和证据质量评价，为临床决策提供参考。

方法

计算机检索中国期刊全文数据库（CNKI）、万方数据知识服务平台（Wanfang）、维普资讯中文期刊服务平台（VIP）、中国生物医学文献服务系统（SinoMed）、Cochrane Library、PubMed 和EMbase数据库，收集针灸治疗小儿脑瘫疗效的系统评价/Meta分析，检索时间为建库至2022年6月30日。使用AMSTAR 2量表评估文献的方法学质量，使用PRISMA量表对文献报告质量进行评分，使用GRADE量表对证据质量进行分级。

结果

最终纳入14篇系统评价，共37个结局指标，通过AMSTAR 2评价纳入文献的方法学质量，4篇为低质量，10篇为极低质量文献，得分较差的条目为2、4、7、10、16。PRISMA评分为15~25分，报告质量问题主要体现为结构式摘要、方案和注册、检索、资金等方面。GRADE分级结果显示，高质量证据3个，中等质量证据7个，低质量证据10个，极低质量证据17个，降级因素主要为局限性、不精确性及发表偏倚。

结论

针灸治疗小儿脑瘫有一定疗效，但纳入文献的方法学质量、报告质量、证据质量均较差，且不同针灸方法之间的疗效比较尚不明确。

Abstract

Objective

To assess the methodological quality

report quality and evidence quality of the Meta-analysis and systematic reviews of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy

aiming to provide decision-making basis for clinical treatment.

Methods

The systematic reviews and Meta-analysis of acupuncture and moxibustion for children with cerebral palsy were searched in CNKI

Wanfang

VIP

SinoMed

Cochrane Library

PubMed and EMbase. The retrieval time was from the database establishment to June 30th

2022. AMSTAR 2 (a measurement tool to assess systematic reviews) was used to evaluate the methodological quality， and PRISMA (preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and Meta-analyses) was used to evaluate the report quality

and GRADE was used to evaluate the quality of evidence.

Results

A total of 14 systematic reviews were included

including 37 primary outcome indexes. According to AMSTAR 2 evaluation results

there were 4 low quality studies

10 very low quality studies

and low scores on items 2

10 and 16. PRISMA scores ranged from 15 to 25

and the main reporting problems reflected in structured abstracts

program and registration

retrieval

and funding sources

etc. According to the GRADE classification results

there were 3 high quality evidences

7 medium quality evidences

10 low quality evidences and 17 very low quality evidences. The main downgrading factors were limitations

imprecision and publication bias.

Conclusion

Acupuncture and moxibustion has a certain effect for cerebral palsy in children

but the quality of methodology

reporting and evidence in the included literature is poor

and the comparison of curative effect between different acupuncture and moxibustion methods is unclear.

关键词

Keywords

references

李晓捷 , 唐久来 , 马丙祥 , 等 . 脑性瘫痪的定义、诊断标准及临床分型 [J ] . 中华实用儿科临床杂志 , 2014 , 29 ( 19 ): 1520 .

Wu CS , Pedersen LH , Miller JE , et al . Risk of cerebral palsy and childhood epilepsy related to infections before or during pregnancy [J ] . PLoS One , 2013 , 8 ( 2 ): e57552 .

Soleimani F , Vameghi R , Biglarian A . Antenatal and intrapartum risk factors for cerebral palsy in term and near-term newborns [J ] . Arch Iran Med , 2013 , 16 ( 4 ): 213 - 216 .

Wu YW , Kuzniewicz MW , Wickremasinghe AC , et al . Risk for cerebral palsy in infants with total serum bilirubin levels at or above the exchange transfusion threshold: a population-based study [J ] . JAMA Pediatr , 2015 , 169 ( 3 ): 239 - 246 .

Sadowska M , Sarecka-Hujar B , Kopyta I . Cerebral palsy: current opinions on definition, epidemiology, risk factors, classification and treatment options [J ] . Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat , 2020 , 16 : 1505 - 1518 .

唐久来 , 秦炯 , 邹丽萍 , 等 . 中国脑性瘫痪康复指南(2015): 第一部分 [J ] . 中国康复医学杂志 , 2015 , 30 ( 7 ): 747 - 754 .

封玉霞 , 庞伟 , 李鑫 , 等 . 中国0~6岁儿童脑瘫患病率的Meta分析 [J ] . 中国全科医学 , 2021 , 24 ( 5 ): 603 - 607 .

中国康复医学会儿童康复专业委员会 , 中国残疾人康复协会小儿脑性瘫痪康复专业委员会 , 中国医师协会康复医师分会儿童康复专业委员会 , 等 . 中国脑性瘫痪康复指南(2022): 简介 [J ] . 中华实用儿科临床杂志 , 2022 , 37 ( 12 ): 885 - 886 .

李晓捷 , 庞伟 , 孙奇峰 , 等 . 中国脑性瘫痪康复指南(2015): 第七部分 [J ] . 中国康复医学杂志 , 2016 , 31 ( 1 ): 118 - 128 .

艾克拜尔·艾尔肯 , 周钰 , 夏武雪 . 针灸治疗小儿脑瘫的临床研究进展 [J ] . 新疆中医药 , 2022 , 40 ( 2 ): 68 - 70 .

郑倩茹 . 头针改善小儿脑瘫临床症状的系统评价 [D ] . 成都 : 成都中医药大学 , 2014 .

牛相来 , 马军虎 , 周伟 , 等 . 头针治疗小儿脑瘫临床疗效的Meta分析 [J ] . 中国中西医结合急救杂志 , 2015 , 22 ( 4 ): 347 - 350 .

凌恩 , 方伟杰 , 廖东山 , 等 . 系统评价针刺改善脑瘫患者肌肉痉挛的作用 [J ] . 光明中医 , 2016 , 31 ( 7 ): 990 - 993 .

陈绩锐 , 余小江 , 胡小利 , 等 . 针刺结合康复疗法治疗脑瘫的Meta分析 [J ] . 中国中医基础医学杂志 , 2014 , 20 ( 3 ): 375 - 377 .

卯荣梅 , 赵博 . Meta方法评价中医药文献的商榷 [J ] . 医学与哲学 , 2019 , 40 ( 24 ): 72 - 74 .

张方圆 , 沈傲梅 , 曾宪涛 , 等 . 系统评价方法学质量评价工具AMSTAR 2解读 [J ] . 中国循证心血管医学杂志 , 2018 , 10 ( 1 ): 14 - 18 .

Shea BJ , Hamel C , Wells GA , et al . AMSTAR is a reliable and valid measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews [J ] . J Clin Epidemiol , 2009 , 62 ( 10 ): 1013 - 1020 .

Shea BJ , Reeves BC , Wells G , et al . AMSTAR 2: a critical appraisal tool for systematic reviews that include randomised or non-randomised studies of healthcare interventions, or both [J ] . BMJ , 2017 , 358 : j4008 .

高亚 , 刘明 , 杨珂璐 , 等 . 系统评价报告规范:PRISMA 2020与PRISMA 2009的对比分析与实例解读 [J ] . 中国循证医学杂志 , 2021 , 21 ( 5 ): 606 - 616 .

Guyatt G , Oxman AD , Akl EA , et al . GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction-GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables [J ] . J Clin Epidemiol , 2011 , 64 ( 4 ): 383 - 394 .

Brozek JL , Akl EA , Alonso-Coello P , et al . Grading quality of evidence and strength of recommendations in clinical practice guidelines. Part 1 of 3. An overview of the GRADE approach and grading quality of evidence about interventions [J ] . Allergy , 2009 , 64 ( 5 ): 669 - 677 .

Li LX , Zhang MM , Zhang Y , et al . Acupuncture for cerebral palsy: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J ] . Neural Regen Res , 2018 , 13 ( 6 ): 1107 - 1117 .

Li LY , Liu ZH , Xie QL . Meta-analysis on scalp acupuncture based therapy in treating children cerebral palsy [J ] . World J Acupunct-Moxibust , 2014 , 24 ( 3 ): 49 - 53 .

Xue YM , Shi S , Zheng S , et al . Therapeutic effect of scalp-based acupuncture and moxibustion as an adjunctive treatment on children with cerebral palsy comparing to conventional rehabilitation therapy: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials [J ] . Transl Pediatr , 2022 , 11 ( 5 ): 631 - 641 .

苑金美 , 娄淑哲 , 余利忠 , 等 . 针灸治疗小儿脑瘫随机对照临床Meta分析 [J ] . 新中医 , 2015 , 47 ( 1 ): 227 - 229 .

余利忠 , 苑金美 , 张智慧 , 等 . 针灸治疗小儿脑瘫随机对照临床研究文献Meta分析 [C ] // 第十七届针灸对机体功能的调节机制及针灸临床独特经验研讨会会议论文集 . 兰州 , 2014 : 143 - 146 .

朱静 , 张立勇 , 邵湘宁 . 针灸治疗小儿脑瘫的Meta分析 [J ] . 中医药导报 , 2013 , 19 ( 11 ): 62 - 65 .

廖丛 , 周江堡 . 针灸治疗脑瘫的Meta分析 [J ] . 中国全科医学 , 2011 , 14 ( 11 ): 1229 - 1231 .

王栩 , 杜元灏 , 熊俊 , 等 . 针灸与康复疗法治疗小儿脑性瘫痪疗效比较的系统评价 [J ] . 辽宁中医杂志 , 2011 , 38 ( 3 ): 408 - 413 .

陈智 . 针刺治疗小儿脑性瘫痪的系统评价 [D ] . 成都 : 成都中医药大学 , 2013 .

向娟 , 薛智慧 , 陈果 , 等 . 针刺治疗小儿脑瘫疗效的Meta分析 [J ] . 中国中医药现代远程教育 , 2015 , 13 ( 20 ): 78 - 80 .

王禹毅 , 王丽琼 , 柴倩云 , 等 . 国内针刺随机临床试验文献中对照类型的分析 [J ] . 世界中医药 , 2014 , 9 ( 10 ): 1264 - 1268 .

苏春香 . 针刺随机对照试验报告偏倚的评价研究 [D ] . 北京 : 北京中医药大学 , 2015 .

靳英辉 , 吴世文 , 拜争刚 , 等 . 系统评价与Meta分析的内涵及价值 [J ] . 同济大学学报(医学版) , 2019 , 40 ( 1 ): 105 - 111 .

杨克虎 , 刘雅莉 , 袁金秋 , 等 . 发展和完善中的系统评价再评价 [J ] . 中国循证儿科杂志 , 2011 , 6 ( 1 ): 54 - 57 .

Views

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

A new model of precision acupuncture regulation for emotional disorders based on the AI4S paradigm

New concepts and methods for future clinical research on acupuncture and moxibustion

LYU Jingshan's experience in treatment of post-stroke depression with acupuncture and moxibustion

Efficacy prediction of acupuncture and moxibustion combined with conventional treatment for PCOS-IR based on real-world data: machine learning and interpretability analysis

Modern mechanisms of acupuncture and moxibustion in treatment of functional gastrointestinal diseases based on holistic view

Related Author

ZHAO Yanan

LUO Yi

GU Xiaochai

XIN Chen

ZHAO Chen

RONG Peijing

WANG Yu

YAN Shiyan

Related Institution

Institute of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences

Institute of Basic Research in Clinical Medicine, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences

International Acupuncture and Moxibustion Innovation Institute, Beijing University of CM

School of Acupuncture-Moxibustion and Tuina, Beijing University of CM

Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Shanxi Provincial Hospital of Acupuncture and Moxibustion

⁰